David Moyes has been clear about the scale of the problem facing Everton right now. With the summer window closed, the manager has only one senior striker on the books in Thierno Barry. That reality has left the club scouring the free agent market in search of immediate reinforcements, and Mauro Icardi has emerged as the name generating the most attention among supporters.
The 33-year-old Argentine forward became available after his contract with Galatasaray expired at the end of last season. Reports from ESPN journalist Luiz Carlos Largo suggested Everton were considering him as an option following the collapse of a move for Folarin Balogun. Icardi has a proven record, having scored 77 goals in his time at Inter Milan before moving to Turkey, and sources indicate he would be open to a Premier League switch.
Moyes himself confirmed last week that the squad is “really small” and that the club is looking at free agents to plug gaps. The situation stems from a chaotic deadline day where Beto departed for Fiorentina and the Balogun deal fell through despite significant interest. Everton now head into the early weeks of the season with limited attacking options up front.
The Icardi Option
While some outlets have linked the veteran with a possible move to Goodison Park, recent updates from inside the club suggest caution. BBC gossip columns reported that Everton sources have played down any imminent deal for Icardi or fellow free agent Anthony Martial. This reflects the club’s careful approach to post-window signings, where wages and squad registration rules add extra layers of complexity.
For Everton fans, the debate centres on whether a short-term fix like Icardi would truly address the underlying issue. The forward has not played in England before and would need time to adapt, yet his goal-scoring pedigree offers an appealing contrast to the current thin resources. Supporters are acutely aware that the club cannot afford another season hampered by a lack of firepower.
The broader context is one of frustration after a transfer window that promised progress but delivered disappointment. New signings arrived in other areas, including Ainsley Maitland-Niles and a loan return for Jack Grealish, but the failure to secure a reliable centre-forward has left Moyes with difficult decisions ahead of upcoming fixtures.
Everton sit eighth in the Premier League table after three games, but the squad depth concerns are real. With only 18 first-team outfield players available in some counts, any injury or suspension could quickly expose the limitations. The manager has been candid about the need for more bodies, and the free agent route remains the most realistic path in the coming weeks.
What makes this particularly significant is the timing. Everton face a run of games that will test their resources, and the lack of a proven goal threat up front risks undermining the positive elements of the summer recruitment. Fans will be watching closely for any further developments on Icardi or alternative targets, hoping the club can resolve the striker issue before it becomes a major problem.




